
The best things in life are on the other side of difficult conversations. Kwame Christian
Key Takeaway: A year-end review should confirm conversations which have already happened. Anything in it which would surprise the employee points to a conversation which was due earlier.
Year-end reviews are on the calendar, and for too many employees they are also the first time a concern gets said out loud. A review is a summary of the year. When the summary contains news, the year did not contain the conversations it should have.
Picture an employee who learns in November that a habit from last spring has been a concern all year. Nobody mentioned it in the one-on-ones. The manager noticed early, decided to wait and see, and the habit faded into the background of a busy year. Now it appears in writing, with a rating attached. The employee is not thinking about the habit. They are thinking about eight months of silence.
Surprises run in both directions. I once gave someone a better review than they had rated themselves. It was eye-opening, because they were much harder on themselves than I or their peers had been. That gap was information, and a review is a late place to learn it.
A review is not where feedback starts. It is where feedback gets summarized. Timing does most of the work. Feedback given within days of a behavior and specific enough to act on gets used. Feedback given six months later has to be rebuilt from memory, which is why it sounds like a judgment.
A standing one-on-one is the system which makes timely feedback routine. My JHC Effective 1:1 Template℠ sets aside five to ten minutes of every meeting for a feedback exchange, so what the manager has noticed, and what the employee has noticed, gets said while it is fresh. If a review would surprise someone, the conversation was due months earlier.
Before you write a review, list every concern and every piece of recognition it will contain. Mark each one: have I said this to the person, with a specific example, close to when it happened? Anything marked no is a surprise. Have that conversation this month, before the review, so the review can confirm it.
A year-end review looks backward. A career conversation looks forward. When both happen in the same meeting, the rating tends to swallow the conversation about growth. My JHC Career Conversation Template℠ is built to be held on its own, at least once a year, with preparation from both people and a 90-day development plan at the close.
In my corporate career, career conversations were held quarterly at minimum. The year-end review had three parts: the employee's self-evaluation, 360-degree feedback, and my final written evaluation. The usual process then delivered that evaluation in the same meeting as the compensation discussion. Personally I would have separated the two, so the person could hear the evaluation without fixating on the money.
The JHC Feedback Culture℠ starts from a simple stance: call people forth, not out. The aim of a hard conversation is to help someone fulfill their potential, and that is easier to believe when the conversation happens early, in private, and with a specific example.
The JHC Performance Conversation Guide℠ walks through four steps for any performance conversation, formal or informal:
Held close to the behavior, these four steps are a conversation. Held at year end, they are a judgment.
Before any year-end review is written, list every concern and every piece of recognition it will contain. Mark each one for whether you have already said it to the person, with an example. Every no is a conversation to have now, while the review is still unwritten, and the next one-on-one is a good place for it.
If you are heading into review season and want help structuring those conversations, a coaching conversation is a good place to start. Schedule a call here 👉 30 minute introduction
About Jeff Hill
Jeff Hill is a leadership coach and the founder of Jeff Hill Consulting, LLC. He works with leaders in nonprofit, private, government, and Faith-Based organizations to build the clarity, systems, and behaviors which make sustained leadership possible.